Koste Chartered Quantity Surveyors 1300 669 400  |  info@koste.ai

Owning Property · Koste Knowledge Base

How to Resolve Disputes with Your Property Manager

Published 26 June 2026 · Last updated 26 June 2026

Quick Answer

To handle a dispute with your property manager, start by reviewing your management agreement and documenting all communication. Attempt to resolve the issue directly and professionally. If unresolved, consider mediation through your state's relevant tenancy authority. Legal advice may be necessary if the dispute escalates.

Disputes with property managers can arise from misunderstandings, unmet expectations, or breaches of contract. Resolving these disputes effectively is crucial to maintaining your property's value and ensuring a smooth management experience.

First, review your management agreement. This document outlines the responsibilities of both parties and should clarify the terms under which the property manager operates. Pay attention to clauses regarding dispute resolution, as well as the manager's duties concerning maintenance, rent collection, and tenant relations.

Document every interaction with your property manager, including emails, phone calls, and meetings. Detailed records can be invaluable if the dispute escalates. Attempt to resolve the issue directly by clearly communicating your concerns and desired outcomes. Keep your communication professional and focused on facts rather than emotions.

To see how this plays out, consider a scenario where a property manager fails to address a significant maintenance issue, leading to tenant dissatisfaction and potential loss of rental income. If your manager consistently overlooks such issues, your investment could suffer. Suppose you own a 3-bedroom house in Melbourne valued at $900,000, and due to unresolved maintenance, you lose a tenant for two months. With a weekly rent of $600, this results in a loss of $4,800.

In our experience reviewing thousands of properties across Australia, unresolved disputes often stem from vague agreements and poor communication. Many investors underestimate the importance of setting clear expectations from the outset. Regularly reviewing the performance of your property manager and addressing issues early can prevent disputes from escalating.

The answer can differ depending on your situation. If the property manager was engaged before significant legislative changes, such as those affecting tenancy laws, older agreements might not reflect current standards. For properties under joint ownership, ensure all owners are aligned on dispute resolution strategies. In cases involving commercial properties, different legal frameworks may apply, requiring specialised advice.

Complex disputes may require professional advice. A Chartered Quantity Surveyor can provide an unbiased assessment of management practices, while a lawyer can offer legal guidance. Both professionals can help ensure your property interests are protected.

  • Review your property management agreement thoroughly.
  • Document all interactions with your property manager.
  • Attempt to resolve issues directly and professionally.
  • Contact your state's tenancy authority if needed.
  • Seek legal advice for complex disputes.
  • Consider changing property managers if disputes remain unresolved.
  • Frequently Asked Questions

    What should I do if my property manager is unresponsive?

    Start by documenting all attempts to contact them. If there's no improvement, consult your management agreement for next steps, which may include contacting a state tenancy authority.

    How can mediation help in a dispute with my property manager?

    Mediation provides a neutral platform to discuss issues with the help of a trained mediator. It can lead to a mutually agreeable solution without escalating to legal action.

    Are there different rules for commercial properties?

    Yes, commercial properties often fall under different legal frameworks. It's crucial to consult with a professional familiar with commercial property laws.

    How do I change property managers if disputes remain unresolved?

    Review your management agreement for termination clauses. Provide written notice as required and ensure a smooth transition to a new manager.

    How does handling a dispute affect my tax return?

    Legal and mediation fees related to managing your investment property may be tax-deductible. Consult your accountant to understand the implications.

    Related Articles

    Read Full Article Free Calculator
    property managementlandlord advicedispute resolutionrental propertyinvestment property

    Written by Koste Team · Koste Chartered Quantity Surveyors · AIQS Member · RICS Member · TPB Registered · 1300 669 400 · info@koste.ai